Tricolor Cookies
a.k.a. The Boss
Three layers, a dark chocolate top and the colors of the old country. Always the first thing gone from the tray.
Add to my order: Tricolor Cookies
The Cookie Cartel · New Jersey
Making cookies you can't refuse.
Custom cookies, Italian favorites and gift-ready trays for every celebration in New Jersey. Wrapped, ribboned and impossible to say no to.
The family business
Every family has its rules. Ours are simple.
We bake custom cookies and Italian favorites for the moments that bring everybody to the table: birthdays, holidays, graduations and every Sunday in between. Every order gets the full treatment, from the first sprinkle to the last loop of ribbon.
Rule 1: Bake it right.
Clean layers, golden edges, sprinkles right where they belong. The details are the whole point.
Rule 2: Wrap it beautiful.
Cellophane, a red-white-and-green ribbon and the Cartel seal. It should look like a gift before anyone takes a bite.
Rule 3: Never show up empty-handed.
Birthdays, holidays, Sunday dinner. If there's a table, there should be cookies on it.
Chapter II · The Tricolor
Three layers. One family secret.
The rainbow cookie, done right: tender layers stacked in red, white and green and finished with a dark chocolate top. The one everybody asks for by name.
- Rosso
- Bianco
- Verde
The lineup
The usual suspects.
Each one has a record at birthdays, showers, graduations and holiday tables across New Jersey. Pick your favorites and we’ll add them to your order.
Funfetti Cookies
a.k.a. The Life of the Party
Crinkled, sugar-dusted and loaded with sprinkles. Nobody walks past these without taking two.
Add to my order: Funfetti Cookies
Italian Knots
a.k.a. The Old School
The Italian-bakery classic, twisted tight and finished sweet. The cookie your grandmother would approve of.
Add to my order: Italian Knots
Dot Cakes
a.k.a. The Showstopper
A cup of soft cake under a crown of nonpareils, dressed in your party's colors from top to bottom.
Add to my order: Dot Cakes
Cookie Trays
a.k.a. The Whole Family
A mixed assortment built for the table. Stacked, shareable and guaranteed to start a conversation.
Add to my order: Cookie Trays
Gift Boxes
a.k.a. The Offer
Cellophane, a tricolor ribbon and the Cartel seal on top. The gift they can't refuse.
Add to my order: Gift Boxes
Chapter III · The Showstopper
Every party needs one big moment.
A crown of nonpareils, a cup of soft cake and your colors from top to bottom. Keep scrolling and watch it go. Scroll back and we’ll put it back together. Nobody has to know.
Occasions
Name the occasion.
We’ll bring the cookies. Pick one to start your order with it already filled in.
- BirthdaysColors and themes made for the guest of honor.Start a birthdays order.
- PartiesTrays that turn any table into a spread.Start a parties order.
- FavorsLittle thank-yous your guests will actually eat.Start a favors order.
- GraduationsCap off the big day in school colors.Start a graduations order.
- HolidaysItalian favorites for the tables that matter most.Start a holidays order.
- Teacher GiftsThe thank-you that gets remembered.Start a teacher gifts order.
- Team CelebrationsYour team's colors, sprinkled on thick.Start a team celebrations order.
- Family GatheringsSunday dinner deserves a proper dessert.Start a family gatherings order.
- EventsShowers, openings, office parties and everything in between.Start a events order.
- Something ElseTell us what you're planning. We like a challenge.Start a something else order.
How it works
How business gets done.
Tell us the job.
Send the order form below, DM us on Instagram, or drop us an email with your date, the occasion and roughly how many guests you're feeding.
We talk it over.
We'll come back to you with options, pricing and timing, plus ideas for colors, themes and presentation.
Consider it handled.
Once the details are locked in, your order is confirmed and we get baking. All that's left is to show up and take the credit.
The earlier you reach out, the more we can do, especially around the holidays.
The order book
Start your order.
Tell us what you’re celebrating. We’ll reply to confirm the details, pricing and timing. No payment needed to ask.
Rather reach us directly?
DM @thecookiecartel_nj on InstagramOur territory
Serving New Jersey.
Wherever the party is in the Garden State, tell us your town when you order and we’ll work out the best way to get your cookies to you.
Start an orderWord on the street
Questions, answered.
Still wondering? Send us a DM at @thecookiecartel_nj. We don’t bite. Our cookies, on the other hand…
How do I place an order?
Fill out the order form on this page or send us a DM on Instagram at @thecookiecartel_nj. Tell us your date, the occasion and roughly how many people you're feeding, and we'll take it from there.
How far in advance should I order?
As early as you can, especially for holidays, graduations and busy weekends. Reach out with your date and we'll let you know what's possible.
Can you match my colors or theme?
Custom is what we do. Share your colors, theme or a photo for inspiration, and we'll talk through what we can create for your celebration.
What's on the menu?
Regulars in the lineup include tricolor rainbow cookies, Funfetti cookies, Italian knots, dot cakes, cookie trays and gift boxes. Ask what's baking for your date when you reach out.
Do you offer pickup or delivery?
We serve New Jersey. Let us know your town when you order and we'll go over pickup and delivery options for your date.
Can you accommodate allergies or dietary needs?
Please tell us about any allergies or dietary needs before you order. We'll talk through ingredients with you directly so you can make the right call for your guests.
Is my order confirmed when I send the form?
Not quite yet. Your request starts the conversation, and your order is confirmed once we've agreed on the details, date and price together.
Chapter IV · The Offer
Consider this our offer.
Wrapped in cellophane, tied in red, white and green and sealed with the Cartel’s mark. All that’s missing is your yes.